Boynton Pizza: A Slice of Italian Delight in Boynton Beach

I hadn’t been to Boynton Pizza in years, but I recently moved back to town and decided to give it another try — glad I did! The place is small with just a couple tables outside, mostly for takeout, but the staff is really friendly and the pizza’s made fresh and fast. It’s classic New York-style pizza and the prices are super reasonable, especially compared to other spots around here. I’ve already been back three times — tried sausage, Hawaiian, and the meat lovers stromboli — all hot, fresh, and delicious. Definitely my new go-to for pizza in Boynton Beach.

Love the pizza here! It's thin crust, crunchy, the sauce and the cheese have a really good balance, but honestly for me I would even want MORE! It's very crunchy and you're getting a lot of crust flavor with every bite, but it's VERY solid pizza. I crave it about once a month. They have great service, you feel like family whenever you walk in. But it's a very small place. I only ever order one slice and then I'm happy. I wouldn't want to have to wait in my car after ordering a pie.

As an ex New Yorkers I've always been a bit of a pizza snob . Always trying different restaurants to find anything close to 'real pizza ' , not anymore unless its one Monday everyone needs a day off , they are closed. They make everything when you order it the cutlers eggplant all cooked fresh not reheated after sitting around since last week !!!

This is a relatively small place. I believe it’s mostly take out. Their food is excellent though. So don’t let the lack of tables fool you. They take pride in their food and it shows. Their pizza is a thin crust that is light and tasty. Their toppings are fresh and plenty full. Their sauce is a tad sweet and savory. We adore their pizza. Their Chicken Alfredo is a huge portion, enough for 2 people. It is light and flavorful. Not over kill on the flavor which is nice. Their strombolis are customizable and soooooooooo cheesy and yummy! No to mention they use great meat and veggies to fill them. Their garlic rolls are to die for. Plain and simple. Perfect mix of garlic cheese oil and fluffy rolls! Their steak sub is excellent, the meat is quality and the veggies are fresh. It’s also a good size which is key! If I could give this place more stars I would because this is a Great Pizza Place!

Great slices! We are from Rhode Island and always on the lookout for good pizza. We went off Barstools review so had to check it out ourselves. Great stop. Nice thin New York style pizza. We will definitely be going back here when we are down again.

New to the area and I have to say this place is amazing! The pizza is delicious the pasta even the garlic rolls you definitely have a new client !

I am baffled as to how these guys keep track of their customers… I went from ordering in-house to delivery over the course of 3 years and they always deliver on point to my specifications. Pizza delivery is tricky… when I order an extremely well done traditional cheese pizza, and it gets delivered like I was eating in house, I can give props to the establishment… when I order a Greek salad with extra feta and they don’t skimp on the greens, I can appreciate the attention to customer satisfaction… Boynton Pizza is not to be slighted… these guys have your best interests in mind… I don’t write reviews… ever… yet, I have been managing upscale dining for 15 years… most reviews only post bad reviews… these guys do it right!

The food is AMAZING!! They delivered fast and the food was perfectly hot and delicious! We have shellfish allergies and this place is safe for us. (11/2025). They were patient and thorough going through the menu with me to be sure. The pizza was thin, cooked well, perfect NY style! And the chicken parm sub? Omg I crave it. This is a real review, I dont know them or get anything for this. Just wanted to let people know about an awesome small business!